Renting in the Five Towns
Discover the Charm and Beauty of the Five Towns-Without the Commitment
Renting in the Five Towns offers the perfect blend of flexibility and lifestyle. With access to schools, beaches, close-knit communities, vibrant kosher dining, and quick commutes to Manhattan, it’s ideal for those exploring homeownership or simply seeking refined suburban living. From quiet cul-de-sacs to buzzing village centers, renters get a taste of what makes each neighborhood unique—all with the guidance of locals who know the market best.
Find Your Next Rental in the Five Towns & Beyond
Whether you’re renting, selling, or just exploring, we’re here to help—locally and personally.
Browse the latest listings below from OneKey® MLS — updated in real time.
Contact Us
“Serving the Five Towns and Long Island Communities from Hewlett”
Licensed Office:
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
304 Merrick Rd, Rockville Centre, NY 11570
Office Phone: 516‑342‑0056
Joey Frankel, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson | LIC #10401254223
joey.frankel@elliman.com | 561‑901‑9232
Sandra Carl, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson | LIC #10401348492
sandra.carl@elliman.com | 516‑342‑0056
Insider Secrets About Renting in the Five Towns
1. Off-Market Rentals Exist—But You Need the Right Local Connection
Many of the best rental opportunities never hit Zillow. From private homeowner listings to quiet negotiations through local networks, knowing the right agent is key. We often hear, “I didn’t even know that home was available!” That’s the advantage of working with someone local in the Five Towns.
2. Timing Is Everything—and Locals Know the Rhythm
Some landlords list around holiday breaks or seasonal cycles to attract longer-term tenants. Others prep their properties quietly between school semesters. We know the subtle timing patterns that make all the difference.
More Insider Rental Tips
Rental Pricing Isn’t One-Size-Fits-All
In the Five Towns, pricing often hinges on subtle factors: proximity to specific congregations, parking, school zones, yard access, and even the reputation of a particular block. We help renters identify value beyond what the algorithms show.
4. Co-op and Condo Rentals Come with Gatekeepers
Renting in a co-op or condo often requires board approval, extra documentation, or subtle language in the lease. We navigate the red tape and prepare your board package for success before you apply.
My wife and I could never thank Sandy and Joey enough for their time, guidance, and hard work in helping us sell our home. Upon first meeting them, my wife and I quickly realized how trust-worthy they are. Sandy and Joey truly value their words, they inspire confidence and collaboration. All throughout the sale process, they kept constant communication and went above and beyond to ensure we received the best offer we wanted on our home. We highly recommend Sandy and Joey to anyone who’s looking for an honest and professional team of agents to sell their property. Thank you again Sandy and Joey! May God bless you both abundantly!
-Georges & Marie Jean-Pierre
Thank you Joey and Sandy , the mother-daughter team for helping my finally find the house i’ve been looking for. I met them by accident, at a house i looked at for rent and i knew it wasn’t for me, but only good came out of it eventually. In the very first meeting with them, they immediately unserstood my needs and worked very hard to find me the perfect rental, in the perfect location, and exactly what I wanted. It’s also worth mentioning, that the house I rented already had an offer on the table, but they didn’t give up and took me to see it anyway, and just like that, I got it. Throughout the process they always made sure we have everything needed and made sure all will work out for the best. even after we moved they checked in just to make sure all is ok. such a great customer relationship!
Thank you again for everything!! You guys are very welcoming, professional and kind. you are truly delightful to work with! highly recommended!
-Adi Danot
Call For A Consultation
516-342-0056
Let’s Talk Real Estate the Neighborly Way
*When you drop your email here, you’re giving us the go-ahead to reach out—whether it’s to reply, share updates, or just say hey.
Not feeling it anymore? No worries. You can unsubscribe anytime by clicking the link in our emails or just replying with “Stop.” We’ll respect your inbox.
“Serving the Five Towns and Long Island Communities from Hewlett”
Joey Frankel, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson | LIC #10401254223
joey.frankel@elliman.com | 561‑901‑9232
Sandra Carl, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson | LIC #10401348492
sandra.carl@elliman.com | 516‑342‑0056
